The Religion of Islam  
 

 
Video Categories
 
 


Intro E-Books

Guest Book

Recommend Us
| More
 

Jesus Christ - Son of God? (part 2 of 2): “Son” or “Slave”?

  
Description: An examination of the concept that Jesus is the son of God from Christian sources.  Part two: A look at the orginal Greek and Hebrew words translated to “son”.
By Laurence B. Brown, MD
Published on 07 May 2007 - Last modified on 22 Feb 2009
Viewed: 34629 (daily average: 13) - Rating: 3.7 out of 5 - Rated by: 23
Printed: 1861 - Emailed: 45 - Commented on: 0

Category: Articles > Comparative Religion > Jesus

Christian clergy openly acknowledge that Jesus never called himself “son of God,” however they claim that others did.  This too has an answer.

Investigating the manuscripts that make up the New Testament, one finds that the alleged “sonship” of Jesus is based upon the mistranslation of two Greek words—pais and huios, both of which are translated as “son.”  However, this translation appears disingenuous.  The Greek word pais derives from the Hebrew ebed, which bears the primary meaning of servant, or slave.  Hence, the primary translation of pais theou is “servant of God,” with “child” or “son of God” being an extravagant embellishment.  According to the Theological Dictionary of the New Testament, “The Hebrew original of pais in the phrase pais theou, i.e., ebed, carries a stress on personal relationship and has first the sense of ‘slave.’”[1]  This is all the more interesting because it dovetails perfectly with the prophecy of Isaiah 42:1, upheld in Matthew 12:18: “Behold, My servant [i.e., from the Greek pais] whom I have chosen, My beloved in whom my soul is well pleased …” Whether a person reads the King James Version, New King James Version, New Revised Standard Version, or New International Version, the word is “servant” in all cases.  Considering that the purpose of revelation is to make the truth of God clear, one might think this passage an unsightly mole on the face of the doctrine of divine sonship.  After all, what better place for God to have declared Jesus His son?  What better place to have said, “Behold, My son whom I have begotten …”?  But He didn’t say that.  For that matter, the doctrine lacks biblical support in the recorded words of both Jesus and God, and there is good reason to wonder why.  Unless, that is, Jesus was nothing more than the servant of God this passage describes.

Regarding the religious use of the word ebed, “The term serves as an expression of humility used by the righteous before God.”[2]  Furthermore, “After 100 B.C. pais theou more often means “servant of God,” as when applied to Moses, the prophets, or the three children (Bar. 1:20; 2:20; Dan. 9:35).”[3]  A person can easily get into doctrinal quicksand: “Of eight instances of this phrase, one refers to Israel (Lk. 1:54), two refer to David (Lk 1:69; Acts 4:25), and the other five to Jesus (Mt. 12:18; Acts 3:13, 26; 4:27, 30)…. In the few instances in which Jesus is called pais theou we obviously have early tradition.”[4]  So Jesus did not have exclusive rights to this term, and where it was employed the term “obviously” stemmed from “early tradition.”  Furthermore, the translation, if impartial, should identify all individuals to whom the phrase was applied in similar manner.  Such, however, has not been the case.  Whereas pais has been translated “servant” in reference to David (Acts 4:25 and Luke 1:69) and Israel (Luke 1:54), it is translated “Son” or “holy child” in reference to Jesus (Acts 3:13; 3:26; 4:27; 4:30).  Such preferential treatment is canonically consistent, but logically flawed.

Lastly an interesting, if not key, religious parallel is uncovered: “Thus the Greek phrase pais tou theou, ‘servant of God,’ has exactly the same connotation as the Muslim name Abdallah—the ‘servant of Allah.’”[5]

The symmetry is all the more shocking, for the Holy Qur’an relates Jesus as having identified himself as just this—Abdallah (abd being Arabic for slave or servant, Abd-Allah [also spelled “Abdullah”] meaning slave or servant of Allah).  According to the story, when Mary returned to her family with the newborn Jesus, they accused her of being unchaste.  Speaking from the cradle in a miracle that gave credence to his claims, baby Jesus defended his mother’s virtue with the words, “Inni Abdullah …” which means, “I am indeed a servant of Allah …” (TMQ 19:30)

Translation of the New Testament Greek huios to “son” (in the literal meaning of the word) is similarly flawed.  On page 1210 of Kittel and Friedrich’s Theological Dictionary of the New Testament, the meaning of huios journeys from the literal (Jesus the son of Mary), to mildly metaphorical (believers as sons of the king [Matt. 17:25-26]), to politely metaphorical (God’s elect being sons of Abraham [Luke 19:9]), to colloquially metaphorical (believers as God’s sons [Matt. 7:9 and Heb 12:5]), to spiritually metaphorical (students as sons of the Pharisees [Matt. 12:27, Acts 23:6]), to biologically metaphorical (as in John 19:26, where Jesus describes his favorite disciple to Mary as “her son”), to blindingly metaphorical as “sons of the kingdom” (Matt. 8:12), “sons of peace” (Luke. 10:6), “sons of light” (Luke. 16:8), and of everything from “sons of this world” (Luke 16:8) to “sons of thunder” (Mark 3:17).  It is as if this misunderstood word for “son” is waving a big sign on which is painted in bold letters: METAPHOR!  Or, as Stanton eloquently puts it, “Most scholars agree that the Aramaic or Hebrew word behind ‘son’ is ‘servant.’  So as the Spirit descends on Jesus at his baptism, Jesus is addressed by the voice from heaven in terms of Isaiah 42:1: ‘Behold my servant … my chosen … I have put my Spirit upon him.’  So although Mark 1:11 and 9:7 affirm that Jesus is called by God to a special messianic task, the emphasis is on Jesus’ role as the anointed servant, rather than as Son of God.”[6]

 

Copyright © 2007 Laurence B. Brown; used by permission.

The above excerpt is taken from Dr. Brown’s forthcoming book, MisGod’ed, which is expected to be published along with its sequel, God’ed.  Both books can be viewed on Dr. Brown’s website, www.LevelTruth.com.  Dr. Brown can be contacted at [email protected]



Footnotes:

[1] Kittel, Gerhard and Gerhard Friedrich. p. 763.

[2] Kittel, Gerhard and Gerhard Friedrich. p. 763.

[3] Kittel, Gerhard and Gerhard Friedrich. p. 765.

[4] Kittel, Gerhard and Gerhard Friedrich. p. 767.

[5] Carmichael, Joel. pp. 255-6.

[6] Stanton, Graham N. p. 225.

Previous: Jesus Christ - Son of God? (part 1 of 2): The Meaning of “Son of God”  
Parts of This Article
Jesus Christ - Son of God? (part 1 of 2): The Meaning of “Son of God”
Jesus Christ - Son of God? (part 2 of 2): “Son” or “Slave”?
View all parts together
Article Tools
PoorBest  Rate this article Rate it
Back to top Back to top
Print Print Save this article Save E-mail this article to a friend E-mail PDF Format PDF Format
Add a comment on this article Add a comment View or hide comments on this article View comments (No comments) Add this article to your favorites on this site Site favorites Add this article to Explorer favorites Explorer favorites
| More
Other Articles in the Same Category
Category: Articles > Comparative Religion > Jesus
Jesus Freaks
Where is the “Christ” in “Christianity?”
Jesus’ Greatest Commandment
Religious Mysteries 101 – The Crucifixion
Jesus in Islam (part 1 of 3)
Jesus in Islam (part 2 of 3)
Jesus in Islam (part 3 of 3)
Da Vinci Code Broken?
Is Jesus God? (part 1 of 4)
Is Jesus God? (part 2 of 4)
Is Jesus God? (part 3 of 4)
Is Jesus God? (part 4 of 4)
The Descriptive Titles of Jesus in the Quran (part 1 of 2): “The Messiah” and “a Miracle”
The Descriptive Titles of Jesus in the Quran (part 2 of 2): A “Word” and “Spirit” from God
Trinitarian Verses (part 1 of 4): “A Child Will Be Born To Us…Eternal Father, Prince of Peace”
Trinitarian Verses (part 2 of 4): “His Name Shall Be Immanuel”
Trinitarian Verses (part 3 of 4): Alpha and Omega
Trinitarian Verses (part 4 of 4): Alpha and Omega
The Miracles of Jesus
The Return of Jesus (part 1 of 5)
The Return of Jesus (part 2 of 5)
The Return of Jesus (part 3 of 5)
The Return of Jesus (part 4 of 5)
The Return of Jesus (part 5 of 5)
Divinity of Jesus? An Inquiry
Do Miracles Necessite Divinity?
The Story of Jesus and Mary in the Holy Quran (part 1 of 3): Mary
The Story of Jesus and Mary in the Holy Quran (part 2 of 3): Jesus I
The Story of Jesus and Mary in the Holy Quran (part 3 of 3): Jesus II
The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus (part 1 of 7): Bible’s writers
The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus (part 2 of 7): Acts of the Apostles
The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus (part 3 of 7): Jesus is Not All-Powerful, and Not All-Knowing
The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus (part 4 of 7): The Greatest Commandment in the Bible and the Quran
The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus (part 5 of 7): Paul Believed That Jesus is not God
The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus (part 6 of 7): Evidence from the Gospel of John
The Bible Denies the Divinity of Jesus (part 7 of 7): God and Jesus Are Two Separate Beings
The Story of Jesus in Brief
Jesus, son of Mary (part 1 of 5): Muslims Love Jesus too!
Jesus, son of Mary (part 2 of 5): The Message of Jesus
Jesus, son of Mary (part 3 of 5): The Disciples
Jesus, son of Mary (part 4 of 5): Did Jesus Really Die?
Jesus, son of Mary (part 5 of 5): People of the Book
Discovering the Real Jesus (part 1 of 6): Mark vs. Matthew and Luke
Discovering the Real Jesus (part 2 of 6): The Gospel of John
Discovering the Real Jesus (part 3 of 6): Textual Comparisons (I)
Discovering the Real Jesus (part 4 of 6): Textual Comparisons (II)
Discovering the Real Jesus (part 5 of 6): Textual Comparisons (III)
Discovering the Real Jesus (part 6 of 6): Conclusion
Is Jesus God or sent by God? (part 1 of 2)
Is Jesus God or sent by God? (part 2 of 2)
90 Verses says: Jesus is not God
How We as Muslims Celebrate Christ (part 1 of 2)
How We as Muslims Celebrate Christ (part 2 of 2)
Videos in the Same Category
Category: Videos > Comparative Religion > Jesus
Is Jesus God? (Mailbag series)
Jesus Christ was a Muslim
Can God have a Son? (part 1 of 2)
Can God have a Son? (part 2 of 2)
Jesus (Lifting the Fog series)
The Truth About Jesus
The Original Sin
Historical Messiah
Did Adam Worship Jesus Christ
God Never Became Man
Atonement and The Original Sin
Top 10 Reasons Why Jesus Can't Be God
Is Jesus God? (Part 1 of 2)
Is Jesus God? (Part 2 of 2)
The Concept of Trinity
The Return of Jesus
Trinity and Confusion
The True Gospel of Jesus
Liar, Lunatic, or Lord
The Message of Jesus
Top 10 Reasons Why The Trinity Is Invalid
Where Is the Christ In Christianity?
Common Questions About Islam – Channel 99
Was Jesus A Muslim
5 Reasons Why Jesus isn't the Son of God
8 Reasons Why Jesus is not the SON of God
Misconceptions About Jesus
Religious Mystery of the Crucifixion
Why I Love Jesus
Quoting Jesus
5 Reasons Why Jesus is Not God
Jesus; A Comparative Study (part 1 of 4)
Jesus; A Comparative Study (part 2 of 4)
Jesus; A Comparative Study (part 3 of 4)
Jesus; A Comparative Study (part 4 of 4)
Jesus or Muhammad?
Surah Maryam (Chapter 19 of the Holy Quran)
Jesus: A Prophet of Islam
Is Jesus God?
Islamic belief on Jesus and Salvation
Is Jesus God? (a debate)
Jesus Didn't Die For Your Sins
Jesus Christ: A Messenger of Allah?
Jesus is not God, Son of God or equal to God
Why Jesus is Not Divine (part 1 of 2)
The True Message of Jesus Christ (PBUH)
The Birth of Jesus Christ Was A Miracle
Why Jesus is Not Divine (part 2 of 2)
Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?
Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?
Muslims love Jesus and Muhammad the Last Prophet in Islam
The Similarities and Differences between Islam and Christianity
   

The Religion of Islam Home Page Home Page

Contact Us Contact Us

EnglishEspañol
FrançaisDeutsch
РусскийPortuguês
中文日本語
Italian

  Live Help by Chat  
Online daily:
From  to 
(according to your computer time)

  Login  
Username
Password
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No account? Register & Why?

  Most Popular  

  List Articles  

  Your Favorites

Your favorites list is empty.  You may add articles to this list using the article tools.


  Your History

Your history list is empty.

Disable recording my history