The Religion of Islam  
 

 
Video Categories
 
 


Intro E-Books

Guest Book

Recommend Us
| More
 

Do We Have Good Reasons to Believe? (part 1 of 2)

  
Description: It is logical to believe in a Creator and irrational to believe otherwise.
By onereason.info
Published on 31 Oct 2011 - Last modified on 11 Mar 2012
Viewed: 74322 (daily average: 54) - Rating: 4.6 out of 5 - Rated by: 9
Printed: 278 - Emailed: 1 - Commented on: 0

Category: Articles > Evidence Islam is Truth > Logical Proofs

Why is the universe the way it is?

Goodreasonsto.jpgOne of the most important questions that almost all thinkers, philosophers and people like you and I have asked is “Why does the universe exist at all?  And why is it the way it is?” In response to this question there are those who say that the universe is uncaused, in other words it is eternal, meaning it has no beginning and no end.  If this is true, there should be an infinite history of past events.  However, the infinite in the real world is not possible as it implies a quantity that is limitless.  Let’s take the following examples into consideration: if there were an infinite number of books in a room and two were taken away, how many would be left?  The response may be “infinity” or for those who are logically inclined “infinity minus two”.  In any case, the responses don’t make sense because although two have been taken away from infinity there still remains infinity! Consequently, we’re not able to count the remaining books left in the room.  Therefore the infinite leads to contradictions and simply doesn’t exist in the real world (although it exists in mathematical discourse; however it is based upon certain axioms and conventions).  Therefore, it logically follows that the universe must have a finite history of past events, which indicates that it must have begun to exist at some point in time.

The above may sound too philosophical, but it is also supported by scientific evidence, for instance, Stephen Hawking, in his lecture The Beginning of Time states, “The conclusion of this lecture is that the universe has not existed forever.  Rather, the universe, and time itself, had a beginning in the Big Bang, about 15 billion years ago.”[1]  According to contemporary cosmologists, the universe began at time zero with the event commonly called the “Big Bang”.  The theory postulates that the universe began as a “singularity”, an extremely hot and dense entity that expanded and subsequently cooled, going from something incredibly small and hot to the current size and temperature of our universe.  In light of these facts, it is interesting to note that there is no scientific explanation as to what happened before time zero.  In addition to this, the Big Bang theory can only postulate what happened 1 x 10-34 seconds after the Big Bang but not anytime before it.  What happened before this particular point in time is unknown.

In the context of the above discussion, it can be concluded that generally physicists agree that as a result of the Big Bang, physical time and space were created as were energy and matter.  So two premises can be drawn from all the above: 1. Whatever begins to exist has a cause   2. The universe began to exist - Therefore the universe has a cause.  How do we get to this conclusion?  Well, if everything we know and see that begins to exist has a cause, for example a noise in the room or the pyramids at Giza, then the universe - which also began to exist -must also have a cause.

The Cause for the Universe = God?

Our discussion so far has provided good reasons to believe that there must have been a cause for the universe.  However, this doesn’t tell us much about what the cause is, but if we think deeply about the nature of the cause - also known as conceptual analysis - we can conclude that it must be very powerful as it brought into existence the entire universe, and it must be:

One...

The cause for the universe must be a single cause for several reasons.  An attractive argument to substantiate this claim includes the use of the rational principle called Occam’s razor.  This principle is commonly summarised as “the simplest explanation is the best explanation”.  In philosophical terms the principle enjoins that we should not multiply entities beyond necessity.  What this basically means is that we should stick to explanations that do not create more questions than it answers.  In the case of the cause for the universe we have no evidence to claim multiplicity, in other words more than one, and if we did it would create more questions than it answers.

Uncaused & Eternal...

This cause must also be uncaused due to the absurdity of an infinite regress, in other words an indefinite chain of causes.  To illustrate this better, if the cause of the universe had a cause and that cause had a cause ad infinitum, then there wouldn’t be a universe to talk about in the first place.  For example, imagine if a Stock Trader on a trading floor at the Stock Exchange was not able to buy or sell his stocks or bonds before asking permission from the investor, and then this investor had to check with his, and this went on forever, would the Stock Trader ever buy or sell his stocks or bonds?  The answer is no.  In similar light, if we apply this to the universe we would have to posit an uncaused cause due to this rational necessity.

However, some philosophers and scientists claim that “why doesn’t the cause be the universe itself?” and “why can’t the cause stop at the universe?” Well, the problem with these claims is that they would imply the universe created itself, which is absurd because how can anything exist and not exist at the same time?  Finally, it would be irrational to claim that whatever begins to exist causes itself!

Immaterial...

The cause has to be immaterial since it created everything.  If you were to take any state of physical existence, you would come to the conclusion that, that state of physical existence owes itself to another state of physical existence.  And that state of physical existence, owes itself to another state of physical existence.  But you can’t go back states of physical existences ad infinitum.  There has to be a beginning to the entire state of physical existences.  Therefore, the logical conclusion is that the origin of all creation has to be a non- physical state.  After thinking about the nature of the cause for the universe we come to the remarkable realisation that it has all the basic attributes of the traditional monotheistic God, namely that He is one, eternal and immaterial.  But what reasons do we have to start claiming that a particular religion is true?  This leads us to discuss the Quran, the book of the Muslims.



Footnotes:

[1] (http://www.hawking.org.uk/index.php/lectures/publiclectures/62)

  Next: Do We Have Good Reasons to Believe? (part 2 of 2)
Parts of This Article
Do We Have Good Reasons to Believe? (part 1 of 2)
Do We Have Good Reasons to Believe? (part 2 of 2)
View all parts together
Article Tools
PoorBest  Rate this article Rate it
Back to top Back to top
Print Print Save this article Save E-mail this article to a friend E-mail PDF Format PDF Format
Add a comment on this article Add a comment View or hide comments on this article View comments (No comments) Add this article to your favorites on this site Site favorites Add this article to Explorer favorites Explorer favorites
| More
Other Articles in the Same Category
Category: Articles > Evidence Islam is Truth > Logical Proofs
The Truth is One (part 1 of 2)
The Truth is One (part 2 of 2)
The True Religion (part 1 of 8): Which is the True Religion of God?
The True Religion (part 2 of 8): The Religion’s Name
The True Religion (part 3 of 8): God and Creation
The True Religion (part 4 of 8): The Message of False Religions
The True Religion (part 5 of 8): Universality of God’s Religions
The True Religion (part 6 of 8): Recognition of God
The True Religion (part 7 of 8): The Signs of God
The True Religion (part 8 of 8): Conclusion
Biological Evolution – An Islamic Perspective
Thermodynamics Falsifies Evolution (part 1 of 2)
Thermodynamics Falsifies Evolution (part 2 of 2)
Researching Islam – Suggested Methodology (part 1 of 4): Looking for Proof? Start with Logic
Researching Islam – Suggested Methodology (part 2 of 4): Logical Steps Lead to Logical Conclusions
Researching Islam – Suggested Methodology (part 3 of 4): God’s message is not hidden
Researching Islam – Suggested Methodology (part 4 of 4): God’s Wisdom is Sometimes beyond Our Understanding
Philosophical Reflections (part 1 of 5)
Philosophical Reflections (part 2 of 5)
Philosophical Reflections (part 3 of 5)
Philosophical Reflections (part 4 of 5)
Philosophical Reflections (part 5 of 5)
The Probability of Macroevolution
Fine-Tuning of the Universe (part 1 of 8): Physical Laws
Fine-Tuning of the Universe (part 2 of 8): Constants & Initial Conditions
Fine-Tuning of the Universe (part 3 of 8): Four Examples of Fine-Tuning
Fine-Tuning of the Universe (part 4 of 8): Extreme Examples of Fine-Tuning
Fine-Tuning of the Universe (part 5 of 8): Objections to Fine-Tuning
Fine-Tuning of the Universe (part 6 of 8): How Can We Explain Fine-Tuning?
Fine-Tuning of the Universe (part 7 of 8): Multiple Universes
Fine-Tuning of the Universe (part 8 of 8): Wrap-Up of Fine-Tuning of the Universe
Fine-Tuning of the Universe − Summarized (part 1 of 2)
Fine-Tuning of the Universe − Summarized (part 2 of 2)
God’s Being & the Limits of Human Imagination
Videos in the Same Category
Category: Videos > Evidence Islam is Truth > Logical Proofs
A Proof That Islam Is The Truth
The Religion of Truth
Logic in Islam
Islam: The Inclusive Religion (part 1 of 2)
Islam: The Inclusive Religion (part 2 of 2)
Why is Islam The True Religion?
Islam & the 21st Century
The Argument for Islam
The Rational Response to the Design Argument
Relationship between the Body and the Soul
Philosophy of Science
On Evolution (part 1 of 3)
On Evolution (part 2 of 3)
On Evolution (part 3 of 3)
Why Do I Remain A Muslim?
Evolution and Islam
The Problem of Evil
Why Worship God?
Is Life Just a Game?
Islam: Fairy Tale or Truth
Why does God do this..or that?
   

The Religion of Islam Home Page Home Page

Contact Us Contact Us

EnglishEspañol
FrançaisDeutsch
Русский

Статьи / видео вы запросили еще не существует.

The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet.

Português
中文

您所请求的文章/视频尚不存在。

The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet.

日本語

あなたが要求した記事/ビデオはまだ存在していません。

The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet.

Italian

L'articolo / video che hai richiesto non esiste ancora.

The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet.


  Live Help by Chat  
Online daily:
From  to 
(according to your computer time)

  Login  
Username
Password
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No account? Register & Why?

  Most Popular  

  List Articles  

  Your Favorites

Your favorites list is empty.  You may add articles to this list using the article tools.


  Your History

Your history list is empty.

Disable recording my history